Texas Tribune / Mark Rogers
Marcus Stovall and Bear Brilliant stand on the sidewalk throughout the road from the courthouse on Dec. 9, 2023 in Canyon.
Join The Temporary, The Texas Tribune’s every day publication that retains readers on top of things on essentially the most important Texas information.
West Texas A&M College college students Bear Brilliant and Marcus Stovall held their breath for months.
Sure, college President Walter Wendler canceled final 12 months’s on-campus drag present. However as a lawsuit accusing Wendler of violating college students’ First Modification rights wended via the courts, Brilliant and Stovall booked a scholar heart banquet corridor, secured insurance coverage and arranged almost a dozen performers for the Don’t Be a Drag efficiency slated for Friday night time.
The 2 college students on the college in Canyon, about 20 miles south of Amarillo, didn’t method the brand new occasion as a salvo within the bigger battle over freedom of expression in America that’s nonetheless pending earlier than the fifth U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals. To them, it was about producing a joyful scholar efficiency celebrating queer identities — the form of present that occurs each night time with out controversy in different components of Texas.
Nonetheless, they knew that any time, Wendler might block the present from occurring on campus. However in addition they thought that Wendler’s reasoning for the earlier cancellation exemplified a public official stifling expression as a result of he disagrees with the content material — and was the form of clear-cut censorship the federal court docket system would forestall from occurring once more.
However final week, the U.S. Supreme Courtroom dashed these hopes. The excessive court docket refused, a minimum of for now, to wade into the case and its free speech debate. On Monday, Wendler did precisely what Brilliant and Stovall feared: He once more forbade a drag present from being carried out on campus.
“It was very discouraging and miserable at first,” Brilliant stated.
The Supreme Courtroom solely declined to dam Wendler from canceling one other drag present whereas a lawsuit over the earlier cancellation performs out on the appellate degree. Justices weren’t contemplating the underlying authorized arguments about whether or not Wendler abused his authority to squash the efficiency on the premise of his disapproval of the scholars’ viewpoints. These questions are nonetheless earlier than the fifth Circuit court docket, which has additionally declined to problem an injunction in opposition to Wendler till it hears arguments within the case in April.
The West Texas lawsuit comes a 12 months following Republican state lawmakers’ try to classify all drag reveals as obscene. However after a video of a male GOP legislator carrying a costume for a college theater venture surfaced, state leaders scrapped that model of a invoice and ultimately handed a legislation that prohibits sure drag performances in entrance of kids. However even that watered-down model of Senate Invoice 12 has been deemed unconstitutionally overbroad and imprecise. An enchantment of that call can be earlier than the fifth Circuit.
SB 12 got here on the heels of an anti-drag panic whipped up by a small however influential cadre of activists and extremist teams who routinely characterised all drag as inherently and nefariously sexual, whatever the content material or viewers. Such claims had been then used to justify harassment of the LGBTQ+ neighborhood, typically underneath the guise of defending youngsters.
“It is a part of the nationwide mentality,” stated Claudia Stravato, a component time state and native authorities college member at West Texas A&M. “We form of get morally hysterical on this nation each few years.”
The potential constitutional showdowns over drag reveals additionally are available an period when Texas officers have relied on new state legal guidelines, the lawyer common’s workplace and a newly conservative Supreme Courtroom to assist redraw the authorized boundaries on every little thing from abortion and unlawful immigration to what sorts of well being care transgender youngsters can entry.
And as a authorized limbo persists, LGBTQ+ residents like Brilliant and Stovall acutely really feel politically and socially focused in part of the state the place cultural acceptance of queer individuals already lags behind the state’s massive cities.
“It seems like that LGBTQ+ and queer individuals aren’t welcome anyplace close to right here,” Brilliant stated Thursday, nonetheless recovering from Wendler’s disorienting cancellation earlier this week. “Simply because we’re homosexual or bi or trans … we’re simply not allowed to exist on this space.”
‘Your personal path’
Myss Myka is without doubt one of the most distinguished drag queens within the Texas Panhandle with a efficiency profession that’s spanned almost a decade. Primarily based in Amarillo, she’s mentored quite a few drag artists over time, together with West Texas A&M college students.
She was all set to host the on-campus present Friday, earlier than Wendler canceled it.
The necessity for student-led drag reveals, she stated, is to create a way of neighborhood for younger people who find themselves questioning their place on this planet and looking for connections in it.
“We inform those who, ‘We’re right here for you, we’ll reply any questions that you’ve got and, most significantly, we would like you to have the ability to discover your personal path and discover individuals who you’ll be able to share your struggles with,’” Myka stated.
All through the years, Myka has observed the queer-friendly neighborhood in Amarillo develop. With a inhabitants of greater than 200,000 Amarillo is by far the most important metropolis within the Panhandle. But it surely anchors a largely rural area that is still a staunchly conservative space that’s a number of hours away from any of Texas’ sprawling metro areas the place drag reveals are routine and LGBTQ+ individuals maintain public workplace.
Myka stated the power and affect of the area’s non secular teams and extremist organizations fuels security considerations each time she takes the stage.
Stovall, who had deliberate to carry out on Friday wearing an homage to English novelist Clive Barker’s character referred to as Pinhead within the film “Hellraiser,” shares these security considerations residing in Canyon south of Amarillo.
“If I attempted to hold up a delight flag in my window, I’d in all probability get a rock via it inside an hour,” Stovall stated.
After final 12 months’s drag present was canceled, organizers ultimately discovered a venue off-campus the place they staged a make-up efficiency. Myka hosted that present. With Friday’s showcase canceled, she’s now specializing in emotionally supporting performers as they determine what to do subsequent.
“As queens, we’re all the time form of ready for any form of state of affairs we’re in,” she stated.
Similar topic, totally different conclusionsSince taking the helm of West Texas A&M in 2016, Wendler, who is understood for his outspoken Christian beliefs, has introduced himself as the reply to what conservative lawmakers and activists see as a proliferation of liberal agendas and silencing of conservative views in larger schooling.
When he banned student-led drag reveals on the college’s campus final 12 months, he stated it was as a result of the performances degrade girls.
“Nobody ought to declare a proper to contribute to girls’s struggling through a slapstick sideshow that erodes the price of ladies,” he stated on the time.
He cited those self same causes in one other all-campus e-mail on Monday, canceling the second present. He additionally pointed to the brand new state legislation, SB 12, as a purpose for denying the scholars’ allow. Initially billed as laws that may forestall youngsters from seeing drag reveals, lawmakers ultimately landed on language that doesn’t instantly reference individuals dressing as the other gender. As an alternative, the laws prohibits any performers from dancing suggestively or carrying sure prosthetics in entrance of kids.
A federal choose in Houston blocked the state from implementing the legislation and issued a 56-page ruling concluding that Texas’ new legislation was so imprecise that cheerleading and dancing could possibly be construed to be violations.
“Drag reveals categorical a litany of feelings and functions, from humor and pure leisure to social commentary on gender roles,” the ruling reads. “There is no such thing as a doubt that on the naked minimal these performances are supposed to be a type of artwork that’s meant to entertain, alone this could warrant some degree of First Modification safety.”
Organizers of the drag present stated it was disingenuous for Wendler to quote SB 12 as a purpose to close down the performances for the reason that legislation at present can’t be enforced.
“That simply actually miffed me,” stated Brilliant.
When he and Stovall sought court docket aid from Wendler’s earlier drag ban, their case got here earlier than U.S. District Decide Matthew Kacsmaryk, the only real sitting choose within the Amarillo federal court docket district and an outspoken opponent of LGBTQ+ rights. Former President Donald Trump appointed Kacsmaryk to the bench in 2019. Earlier than that, the choose was deputy counsel for the First Liberty Institute, a deeply conservative non secular liberty legislation agency.
Republican Texas Lawyer Normal Ken Paxton and personal litigants regularly file their most contentious lawsuits in Kacsmaryk’s court docket. And on every little thing from immigration and abortion medicine to teenagers’ entry to confidential contraception, they largely achieved their desired end result.
Not like the Houston choose who blocked Texas’ so-called drag present ban, Kacsmaruk dominated that not all drag reveals could possibly be thought of “expressive conduct” and he sided with Wendler.
Now each circumstances, one in opposition to SB 12 and one in opposition to Wendler, are earlier than the U.S. fifth Circuit Courtroom of Appeals. Oral arguments within the college students’ case are slated for April.
Peter Steffensen, a legislation fellow with the First Modification Clinic at Southern Methodist College Dedman College of Legislation, stated the appellate court docket now has to grapple with a state of affairs during which two decrease courts got here to totally different conclusions on the identical subject material.
“It is an actual concern about whether or not or not the court docket will impose some type of rule that restricts the free expression of concepts and efficiency artwork with a view to, as they are saying, shield minors,” Steffenson stated. His legislation clinic filed a quick in assist of the scholars.
Throughout the nation, different federal courts are fielding related questions. In November, the U.S. Supreme Courtroom refused to reinstate a Florida legislation that penalizes companies for permitting youngsters to view drag reveals till a decrease court docket totally considers the case.
A shock rejection
Wendler is just not the one Panhandle official to successfully block a drag present.
The Amarillo Space Transgender Advocacy Group’s Easter occasion in a Canyon park final 12 months featured drag performers, together with Myka. One protester confirmed up carrying navy fatigues and flashing the Nazi salute. However organizers positioned meals vans in a method that blocked him from most attendees’ sight.
Off-duty cops employed as safety advised AATAG board president Sam Burnett, who’s transgender, that that they had no points, discovered the group simple to work with and provided to function safety once more this 12 months.
However when AATAG filed for a allow for this 12 months’s occasion, Canyon officers denied them, saying cops final 12 months witnessed public questions of safety and lewd habits.
“The group’s allow was denied as a result of points at their 2023 occasion. This determination was made in an effort to safeguard the usage of Canyon’s public areas and all of those that go to them,” Megan Nelson, communications director for the town advised The Texas Tribune in a press release.
Metropolis officers declined to offer particulars in regards to the alleged points, however stated the group’s software charge had been returned.
If cops did witness one thing inappropriate on the 2023 occasion, “Why was it not addressed then? Why was it not addressed for a complete 12 months?” Burnett questioned.
Burnett stated metropolis officers cited the state’s obscenity legislation in denying this 12 months’s software. However that doesn’t make sense to him.
“That is no totally different than girls who’re competing in a pageant,” Burnett stated of drag reveals. “It’s a efficiency of artwork. And so why ought to any efficiency of artwork be hidden or not accessed?”
Burnett and different Panhandle residents stated the political atmosphere has change into more and more hostile to LGBTQ+ residents, mirroring a lot of the rhetoric lawmakers in Austin have adopted to push laws making an attempt to reshape the lives of queer Texans.
Through the 2023 legislative session, Republican lawmakers efficiently barred transgender college athletes from collaborating on sports activities groups that aligned their gender and banned adolescents from accessing gender-transitioning care like puberty blockers and hormone remedy.
The creator of that well being care ban for trans children was state Rep. Tom Oliverson, R-Cypress, who introduced Thursday that he’ll problem incumbent Texas Home Speaker Dade Phelan, a fellow Republican, for the management place. High GOP leaders have attacked Phelan as insufficiently conservative as they try to push the Legislature additional rightward.
However there have been native political battles, too, Burnett stated. His group first hosted an LGBTQ+-friendly Easter occasion in 2022 after Canyon Unbiased College District was pressured to take away a suicide prevention program that talked about LGBTQ+ individuals.
“There’s a curriculum that’s getting used as a teen suicide prevention curriculum that incorporates a transgender particular person and is, in our perception, due to this fact selling transgenderism to highschool college students,” Trinity Fellowship Church Senior Pastor Jimmy Witcher stated throughout a Sunday service in February 2022.
He added this system was supported by pop star Woman Gaga, “in order that kinda tells you every little thing you’ll want to find out about it.”
Canyon ISD didn’t reply to the Tribune’s questions, however a web page on the district’s web site that gives details about a number of hot-button points titled “Simply the Info” says that the the Board of Trustees adopted Hope Squad — a distinct curriculum — because the suicide prevention program.
Through the 2023 faculty board elections, a significant problem amongst candidates and voters was how — or whether or not — colleges ought to assist LGBTQ+ college students. A casual hotline Burnett’s group arrange from LGBTQ+ rang nonstop throughout that election cycle.
“We get so many telephone calls in any respect hours of the day,” Burnett stated. “We’re not a suicide hotline, however on the similar time I am not going to let someone not name and a minimum of have someone to speak to.”
Ready, undeterred
John Hintz was a 22-year-old homosexual man when he moved to Amarillo. He truly discovered assist and understanding at his church, a member of what’s known as the Open and Affirming Congregations of the Texas Panhandle.
Hintz stated that the community’s method to LGBTQ+ individuals is significant at a time when political and social rhetoric — particularly towards transgender individuals — may be so hostile.
“Significantly when you concentrate on younger individuals, understanding that they’ve individuals out right here, that there are individuals that may assist them and imagine them,” Hintz stated.
And, Hintz notes, not everybody within the Amarillo space takes problem with transgender individuals or drag reveals. He stated many have reached out with phrases of assist and luxury.
For younger residents like Brilliant and Stovall, the occasions over the previous few years have made it clear that the mere existence of queerness makes some individuals upset.
“They, royally, would fairly have us simply cover away and fake that we’re all straight Christians on this space,” Brilliant stated.
As of Thursday, the scholars had been planning to reschedule the canceled present, which would require some nimble planning to safe a brand new, off-campus venue and discover a date that works for the opposite drag artists.
And with a probably extremely consequential court docket listening to scheduled for his or her lawsuit on April 15, they’re again to holding their breaths.
This story was supported by the Trans Journalists Affiliation.
Disclosure: Southern Methodist College and West Texas A&M College have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partly by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full record of them right here.
This text initially appeared within the Texas Tribune.
The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and interesting Texans on state politics and coverage. Study extra at texastribune.org.
Subscribe to SA Present newsletters.
Comply with us: Apple Information | Google Information | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Fb | Twitter| Or join our RSS Feed
