Emily Brontë’s 1847 novel Wuthering Heights is a type of basic books assigned in highschool English courses, and it has obtained quite a few movie variations over time, every of which differs in quite a few methods from the supply materials. Purists received’t obtain any reprieve from Emerald Fennell’s 2026 adaptation, with a title that’s stylized as “Wuthering Heights” for good purpose.
Cathy (performed as an grownup by Margot Robbie) and Heathcliff (Jacob Elordi) have identified one another their whole lives, with Cathy’s alcoholic and inveterate gambler father (Martin Clunes) taking in Heathcliff on a whim when he was a boy. The 2 bond as they develop up collectively, though Cathy at all times appears to have an eye fixed on shifting up in society from their comparatively impoverished life-style.
Cathy lastly will get her want when the wealthy Linton household, led by Edgar (Shazad Latif), strikes in down the highway. Regardless of discovering she has emotions for the now grown-up Heathcliff, Cathy sees Edgar as her approach out and agrees to marry him. A scorned Heathcliff flees, returning years later as mysteriously rich. His reappearance ignites one thing in Cathy’s soul, and the 2 interact in a maybe unwise affair.
Fennell (Promising Younger Lady, Saltburn) infuses the dusty materials with an power that’s not sometimes current in tales set on this specific time and place. Except for the occasional Charli XCX track (the singer created an entire idea album for the movie), the movie seems and looks like a interval piece, albeit one which doesn’t get slowed down within the drudgery that may generally come from movies set within the distant previous.
A lot of that has to do with the lust the filmmaker places into the story. Even if you happen to’re not accustomed to Brontë’s e book, you possibly can relaxation assured that Fennell has strayed removed from the textual content, giving Cathy and Heathcliff ideas and actions unthinkable within the nineteenth century. Fennell performs with expectations by opening the movie with audio that includes creaking noises and a person grunting, conjuring up a scenario far totally different than what is definitely occurring, and he or she additionally makes liberal use of rain, sweat, and tears to make the actors attractive.
What she will be able to’t do, nevertheless, is make the 2 lead characters compelling. Cathy is a striver who by no means appears to know what she needs out of life, and Heathcliff goes from a bore to a brute over the course of the movie, with no clear indication that he likes anyone, a lot much less Cathy. Anybody anticipating some type of grand romance shall be disillusioned, as Fennell is way more occupied with making the movie bizarre, like having the partitions of Cathy’s room appear to be her pores and skin, full with freckles.
Robbie and Elordi do effectively sufficient with the fabric, and it’s clear that each of them are dedicated to bringing Fennell’s imaginative and prescient to life. Their types are inclined to stability one another out, and if the story had been dedicated to their characters’ relationship, they is likely to be lauded for his or her chemistry. Ultimately, although, the supporting actors really feel extra fascinating, together with ones performed by Hong Chau, Alison Miller, and Clunes.
This model of Wuthering Heights ought to by no means be construed as an alternative choice to studying the e book for any excessive schoolers on the market. Whereas Fennell makes the movie fascinating together with her technical filmmaking decisions, the story by no means finds its footing because it fails to promote the one factor that it appears to vow.
—
Wuthering Heights opens in theaters on February 13.
