Texas Tribune / Blaine Younger
Gov. Greg Abbott discusses dad or mum empowerment at Annapolis Christian Academy in Corpus Christi on Jan. 31, 2023.
This text is co-published with ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Join ProPublica’s Huge Story e-newsletter to obtain tales like this one in your inbox as quickly as they’re revealed. Additionally, join The Temporary, our every day e-newsletter that retains readers in control on probably the most important Texas information.
As proponents of personal college vouchers racked up win after win throughout the nation in recent times, the biggest Republican-led state within the nation remained stubbornly exterior their grasp — till now.
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott succeeded in persuading major voters to take away from workplace members of his get together who had defied him by voting in opposition to laws that might enable the usage of state cash to pay for personal college tuition.
Abbott’s success campaigning in opposition to fellow Republicans through the major election despatched a transparent message that disloyalty wouldn’t be tolerated even for individuals who supported different priorities he outlined. If the pro-voucher candidates who Abbott supported of their primaries win within the November common election, as many are anticipated to, the governor argues he has the votes to lastly cross laws.
The governor’s voucher campaign represents the end result of greater than three a long time of labor by Christian conservative donors, whose affect in Texas politics has by no means been extra pronounced. They’ve poured hundreds of thousands of {dollars} into candidates and helped lead or fund a community of organizations, such because the influential Texas Public Coverage Basis, a conservative assume tank, to impress Republicans across the problem.
“Texas has been type of an Alamo to the nationwide voucher crowd within the sense that the largest state down South nonetheless hasn’t finished it,” mentioned Joshua Cowen, an schooling coverage professor at Michigan State College who opposes vouchers. “When your complete nationwide messaging technique relies on this unstoppable flood of oldsters rising as much as defeat the woke left within the public faculties and Texas is standing there in the course of the map, the largest state saying no, that’s only a drawback for the general technique.”
Throughout his first eight years as governor, Abbott was comparatively quiet on vouchers. In 2017, he known as on lawmakers to cross such a program for college kids with disabilities. However Abbott, who didn’t reply to questions from ProPublica and The Texas Tribune, hadn’t engaged in political warfare on the difficulty till final 12 months, when he made passing vouchers for all Texas college students a high precedence. He joined the Texas Public Coverage Basis on a “dad or mum empowerment” tour throughout the state and urged church pastors to advocate for such laws from the pulpit.
He additionally twice ordered lawmakers into emergency legislative periods to cross measures associated to “college alternative,” a time period supporters have used to explain applications that function exterior of the standard public college system, together with personal or non secular faculties. However lawmakers, together with 21 from his personal get together, rejected the laws.
Republicans with nationwide ambitions are more and more anticipated to completely assist vouchers, Cowen mentioned, including that Abbott’s GOP counterparts in states like Arizona and Florida had overseen profitable pushes of their state legislatures.
“Vouchers have completely grow to be one of many high problem areas of the litmus take a look at for Republican Celebration energy politics,” Cowen mentioned. “If you wish to be a participant, you must actually push on the doctrine.”
Supporters say voucher applications give dad and mom extra management over their youngsters’s schooling by permitting them to make use of public {dollars} to decide on the colleges they imagine are finest, together with these which might be privately run. Opponents argue that vouchers siphon tax {dollars} from public schooling and permit funding to circulation into personal faculties with out holding them accountable in the event that they fail youngsters.
The difficulty has typically been one which falls alongside partisan traces. However through the years, rural Republicans have damaged with their get together to vote in opposition to vouchers. Public faculties, they’ve reasoned, usually play a significant function in native communities the place personal choices are restricted.
Regardless of polling exhibiting that barely lower than half of Texas registered voters assist vouchers and solely 2% of registered Republican voters listed vouchers as a key problem within the GOP major election, Abbott pursued aggressive campaigns in opposition to lawmakers in his get together who didn’t fall in line. Amongst them have been two incumbents he had endorsed two years earlier.
In concentrating on them, Abbott and his billionaire allies didn’t make vouchers the main focus of marketing campaign promoting however somewhat accused them of being mushy on points like border safety.
“In my district, and I feel I’ve seen it in different districts as effectively, the No. 1 problem was the border,” mentioned state Rep. Steve Allison, a San Antonio Republican who misplaced his major election in March after voting in opposition to vouchers final 12 months. “And faculty alternative was manner down the record and behind the financial system and behind property taxes. In order that’s when he appeared to pivot and say, ‘Properly, these guys are weak on the border. They’ve elevated property taxes.’ All of that was simply completely false.”
The first challenges drew hundreds of thousands in contributions from nationwide teams and billionaire donors like TikTok investor Jeffrey Yass, a Pennsylvania voucher advocate who poured $6 million into Abbott’s marketing campaign. A Texas affiliate of the Betsy DeVos-funded American Federation for Youngsters spent greater than $4 million attacking incumbents, and the federal Membership for Progress political motion committee mentioned it coordinated with one other PAC to spend about $8 million on adverts concentrating on Texas voucher opponents.
Allison misplaced to a challenger who obtained greater than $700,000 in assist from Abbott’s marketing campaign.
“Ever since I’ve been within the Legislature, he’s by no means proven any curiosity in personal college vouchers,” Allison mentioned. “It’s simply troubling the best way it got here out of nowhere after which the best way he turned on these of us that simply couldn’t go together with him on it. And I’ve been with him on every thing, each single problem request he’s made, besides this one.”
An extended push supercharged
Shortly after the March GOP primaries, Abbott obtained a hero’s welcome whereas addressing attendees on the Texas Public Coverage Basis’s annual coverage summit in Austin. He celebrated unseating 5 Republicans and stoked enthusiasm for the runoff elections, which he hoped would safe sufficient wins to cross voucher laws in 2024. (Within the Could major runoff, one other three anti-voucher Republicans have been unseated.)
“We’d not be on the edge of success if it weren’t for TPPF,” Abbott instructed the packed room in March. “I come right here at this time with a coronary heart of gratitude.”
The group has pushed for vouchers since its founding in 1989 by Republican Christian conservative donor James Leininger, who funded a pilot voucher program in his hometown of San Antonio for a number of years. In 1998, billionaire oilman Tim Dunn joined the board, serving as vice chair for greater than a decade as he grew to become one of many state’s most prolific marketing campaign donors. Dunn later helped kind Empower Texans, a extra confrontational group that graded Republican lawmakers in accordance with their adherence to hard-right rules and funneled cash into campaigns in opposition to Republicans deemed insufficiently supportive. These campaigns featured what opponents have known as misleading mailers and an aggressive in-house media operation.
The teams and the pro-voucher billionaires made strategic investments through the years to advance their trigger. In 2006, Leininger, who didn’t reply to questions from the information organizations, spent $2.5 million in an try to oust 5 Home Republicans who voted in opposition to vouchers. Two misplaced their seats. Nonetheless, the Texas Home voted 129-8 in opposition to vouchers the next 12 months.
Dunn and West Texas billionaire evangelical donors Dan and Farris Wilks later contributed hundreds of thousands to Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who breathed new life into the voucher push. “As a conservative chief on many points, it needs to be no shock that conservatives assist me,” Patrick mentioned in a press release concerning the marketing campaign contributions. He added that his assist for college alternative initiatives, together with vouchers, spans a long time.
Neither Dunn nor the Wilks brothers responded to questions concerning the donations or the voucher push. In an opinion piece revealed by the Midland Reporter-Telegram final 12 months, Dunn mentioned he has by no means led statewide college alternative efforts. As a substitute, Dunn argued, he has spent his vitality increase Midland Classical Academy, the non secular personal college he based greater than twenty years in the past.
Regardless of Patrick’s affect within the Senate, which handed voucher laws in 2015 and 2017, the Texas Home rejected the plans these years, and the voucher push largely died out afterward.
The arrival of COVID-19 helped reignite the embers of the motion. TPPF promoted vouchers as the answer to anger over COVID-19 restrictions and political battles over what’s taught in faculties.
In August 2020, TPPF revealed a chunk titled “Coronavirus is forcing a wake-up name on Texas’s schooling alternatives” that known as for schooling {dollars} to observe youngsters to the varsity of their alternative, together with personal faculties.
“I feel quite a lot of voucher supporters noticed COVID and a number of the tradition wars as a window for pushing vouchers,” mentioned David DeMatthews, a College of Texas instructional management and coverage professor who doesn’t assist utilizing taxpayer cash to pay for personal faculties. “Conservative assume tanks like TPPF may also help with the framing and crafting a story to make a really unpopular coverage appear extra palatable.”
Brian Phillips, a spokesperson for TPPF, didn’t reply to particular questions concerning the group’s advocacy however issued a press release anticipating victory subsequent 12 months. “When college alternative laws passes subsequent 12 months, it is going to be as a result of wonderful vigilance of 1000’s of oldsters, college students, educators, policymakers, activists, pastors, volunteers, and, sure, even just a few assume tanks,” he mentioned in a press release.
Whereas pushing for vouchers, TPPF additionally capitalized on debates about how race is taught in public faculties. The group revealed a sequence of tales attacking vital race concept, a sophisticated educational idea that examines systemic racism. The “long-term answer to preventing CRT begins with dad and mom preventing for the fitting to decide on one of the best schooling for his or her youngsters,” TPPF wrote in a July 2021 article that advocated for a system through which “a toddler’s public college funding follows her or him to the varsity of their dad and mom’ alternative.”
Later that 12 months, the main focus amongst pro-voucher forces turned to books with LGBTQ+ themes in Texas college libraries. In a November 2021 fundraising letter, TPPF CEO Kevin Roberts claimed that “pornography and express literature” may very well be discovered in class libraries and that public faculties held college students as a “captive viewers to each Marxist and sexual indoctrination.”
He instructed potential donors that the answer was an all-out push for college vouchers.
“TPPF’s coverage and communications departments are constructing this military of a whole bunch of 1000’s of ‘schooling freedom fighters,’” wrote Roberts, who didn’t reply to a request for remark or to written questions. He later left TPPF to guide the influential conservative Heritage Basis assume tank, the place he helms Venture 2025 to “institutionalize Trumpism.”
It’s “now or by no means,” Roberts wrote. “The time is ripe.”
A full-throated embrace
As TPPF labored to stoke parental anger over public faculties, Abbott had not totally jumped into the fray.
Texas Scorecard, a media outlet fashioned by Empower Texans in 2015 that has since grow to be an impartial nonprofit, highlighted that Abbott had left college alternative off his legislative priorities in his 2021 State of the State handle.
Texas Scorecard, which is chaired by Dunn, didn’t reply to questions or a request for remark.
Dunn and the Wilks brothers closely supported Dallas actual property developer Don Huffines, considered one of Abbott’s far-right challengers, within the 2021 Republican major. Their political motion committee Defend Texas Liberty poured $3.7 million into Huffines’ marketing campaign. Huffines hammered Abbott from the fitting on numerous points, together with criticizing him for not doing as a lot to advertise college alternative as Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis did.
Huffines wrote in a press release to ProPublica and the Tribune that whereas his purpose was to win the election, he “knew that the marketing campaign would power the Governor to undertake lots of my coverage positions, together with college alternative, which has been a precedence of the Nationwide and State Republican Celebration for many years.”
A marketing campaign cease in San Antonio in Could 2022 signaled a brand new section for Abbott: a full-throated embrace of vouchers as a high legislative precedence.
“Empowering dad and mom means giving them the selection to ship their youngsters to any public college, constitution college or personal college with state funding following the scholar,” Abbott mentioned.
After his reelection and all through the 2023 legislative session, Abbott joined TPPF marketing campaign director Mandy Drogin in a sequence of “dad or mum empowerment” rallies throughout the state that promoted the advantages of vouchers.
However even with Abbott’s campaigning, the voucher push failed by the top of the session in Could.
In September, a month earlier than Abbott known as lawmakers again to Austin for an emergency session, TPPF helped arrange a teleconference name through which the governor urged pastors to advertise vouchers throughout Sunday church companies. Throughout the name, Abbott introduced his plan to focus on Republicans in upcoming primaries if they didn’t assist vouchers through the particular session.
He fulfilled his promise this spring.
Kel Seliger, a former state senator who remembers being unsuccessfully focused by Dunn after voting in opposition to vouchers, warned that Abbott’s marketing campaign in opposition to fellow Republicans sends a chilling message.
“It says, ‘Don’t disagree. We don’t essentially care about individuals of conscience or something like that,’” mentioned Seliger, who in 2021 determined to not search reelection. “‘We’ve got little interest in any variety of opinion.’ And that’s a tricky message to ship to individuals you might be obligated to work with.”
Two days after the Could major runoffs, TPPF hosted one other celebratory occasion at its Austin headquarters.
Corey DeAngelis, a senior fellow with the nationwide voucher advocacy group American Federation for Youngsters, whose PAC had spent greater than $7 million within the state as of June, declared Texas the “crown jewel” of the nationwide voucher motion. He predicted even Democratic-led states would observe its lead.
“We gotta get Texas,” mentioned DeAngelis, who didn’t reply to a request for remark. “When Texas comes, the remainder of the monopoly dominoes will begin to fall all throughout the nation.”
The Texas Public Coverage Basis has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full record of them right here.
This text initially appeared within the Texas Tribune.
The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and interesting Texans on state politics and coverage. Be taught extra at texastribune.org.
Subscribe to SA Present newsletters.
Comply with us: Apple Information | Google Information | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Fb | Twitter| Or join our RSS Feed
